Why Name, Image, and Likeness Needs Special Protection in the AI Age
- Mary Vandenack
- AI, Blog, Name, Image & Likeness
Name, image, and likeness (NIL) is the legally protectable economic interest in a person’s identity: the right to control and profit from its commercial use. For much of its history, NIL was a niche concern for celebrity estates and their litigators; in the past few years, it has been in the news for college athletes who have only recently been awarded NIL rights.
Artificial intelligence has changed NIL from being the province of athletes and celebrities. When a convincing replica of someone’s voice or face can be generated from a few minutes of recordings, every identity becomes a potential commercial asset and a potential target. NIL questions are now showing up in ordinary estates, and practitioners who neglect protection risk missing property, misvaluing estates, and leaving families unable to control how a loved one’s identity is used after death.
How AI changes the risk
Three developments have made NIL protection more important in everyday practice.
AI voice and likeness cloning. Generative tools can recreate a voice, face, or performance style with little source material. Unlike traditional misappropriation, which required a photograph or recording of the actual person, a digital replica can produce new content the person never made, at scale, indefinitely. That makes post-mortem control far more consequential than it was when the main risk was an unauthorized photo on a T-shirt.
Influencer and creator monetization. Podcasters, social media creators, and YouTube personalities have built income streams around their identities. Those individuals’ brands can keep earning after death, and the rights to keep earning and to stop others from trading on the persona may pass to heirs.
Platform licensing. Clients routinely grant licenses to their images, recordings, and voice through apps, stock services, and creator platforms, often under terms they never read. Some of those licenses survive death; some now cover AI training or synthetic content. An executor who is unaware that they exist can’t manage, enforce, or terminate them.
Why current law falls short
The legal framework was not built for synthetic media, and its gaps are exactly where AI-era risk concentrates.
- State laws control NIL rights, and the laws vary widely. There is no general federal right of publicity. Each state decides whether NIL rights exist, whether they survive death, and for how long. Post-mortem terms range from none at all to a century, depending on the state.
- Protected attributes differ by state. Some statutes protect name and likeness but say little about voice or simulated performances. Tennessee’s ELVIS Act (2024), for example, expressly added voice, including simulated voice, a gap that remains open in many states.
- Domicile can decide everything. Courts generally apply the law of the decedent’s domicile at death to determine whether a post-mortem right exists. The Marilyn Monroe and Princess Diana litigation showed that a generous statute in one state does not help an estate whose decedent was domiciled somewhere without a descendible right.
- Privacy claims die with the person. The appropriation tort is generally personal, so families without a descendible publicity right may have few tools against a posthumous digital replica.
- Federal reform is unsettled. Proposals such as the NO FAKES Act would create federal protection against unauthorized digital replicas, but practitioners should confirm current status before planning around them.
The combination of factors means that an AI-generated replica may be actionable in one state and lawful in the next.
The estate planning stakes
Where state law treats NIL as a descendible property right, it can be includable in the gross estate and must be valued at fair market value. That valuation turns on projected licensing income, existing deals, and marketability.
Estate of Jackson v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2021-48, shows how far apart those numbers can be. The estate reported Michael Jackson’s image and likeness at roughly $2,000; the IRS asserted roughly $434 million; the Tax Court landed near $4 million. Few clients will face numbers like that, but the case shows that NIL valuation is contested, method-driven, and worth getting right from the start.
AI raises the stakes on both sides of the ledger. A replicable voice or likeness may support new licensing income, which raises value. It may also be exposed to unauthorized exploitation that erodes value unless someone has clear authority to enforce. Legislatures are responding: California enacted digital-replica protections for deceased personalities and performers in 2024, and other states have followed with their own amendments. Each change can affect both what an estate owns and what a fiduciary must police.
AI has also brought NIL complications into the mainstream; even a modest estate may hold descendible publicity or likeness rights, and those rights now carry more upside and more risk than ever.
A five-step NIL protection checklist
- Identify and inventory NIL assets. Catalog endorsement and license agreements, creator accounts, trademarks, voice and image libraries, and platform terms, including any that permit AI training or synthetic content.
- Identify governing law. Confirm domicile and any alternative nexus that could affect the existence and duration of post-mortem rights. Check which attributes, including voice and digital replicas, the governing statute protects.
- Secure authority and notify counterparties. Provide letters of authority to every licensee and platform, update the payee and EIN, and gather copies of every license for compliance review. Fiduciaries can’t police unauthorized AI uses they don’t know about.
- Retain a specialist to value the right. Use an appraiser experienced in publicity rights and intellectual property, not a generalist, and build the report to withstand IRS scrutiny.
- Create a strategy for handling NIL after death. Name who controls the persona, whether AI recreations are permitted and on what terms, and give the fiduciary express licensing and enforcement authority in the will or trust.
Conclusion
AI has turned identity into an asset that can be copied, scaled, and exploited without the person’s participation, and possibly long after their death. The law protecting that asset remains fragmented, state-specific, and in flux. That combination is exactly why NIL deserves deliberate attention in every estate plan, not just the ones involving famous clients.
The lawyers who inventory NIL early, pin down governing law, and draft clear authority over digital replicas will give their clients’ families something the law alone cannot: control.
Â
This post is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. Statutes and case law in this area are changing quickly; verify current authority before relying on it.